Wisconsin Cheeseman Reviews

I ordered through the website and it was a smooth experience overall. Finding what I needed was simple, and checkout went through without any problems. The only thing was that it took me a minute to spot the gift options, but once I found them, everything was fine. I’d definitely order again.

The cheese tasted okay, but it arrived warm and was already kind of melted, which was disappointing. I also wasn’t really sure what I was supposed to do next, there weren’t clear instructions about whether to contact support, request a replacement, or just toss it. Overall, not the best experience

I ordered a cheese gift box, the portions were better than I thought they'd be for snacking. They weren't huge or anything, but there was enough for a few people to sample everything without feeling too shorted. A couple of the pieces did look smaller than I expected, so I’m not totally sure I’d call it generous, but overall it seemed fair enough. I’d probably get it again around the holidays

In my experience, the cheese gift box I ordered from wisconsincheeseman.com arrived in really good shape. Everything still felt nicely chilled when it got to me, and to me, it tasted fresh instead of having that weird “been sitting in the fridge too long” flavor.

We opened it up that same night, i thought everything was delicious. Shipping went smoothly too, so based on how fresh it seemed to me, I’d definitely consider ordering again.

The gift basket was packaged really cute and looked great at first glance, but i was still a little disappointed overall.

I used a promo code when ordering some cheese gifts and ended up saving a little, which was definitely appreciated. The discount wasn’t huge, but hey, every bit helps. Overall, it made the purchase feel like a better deal

I sent a cheese box to my parents, and they ended up really liking it. They said everything tasted fresh, and it was fun for them to try a few different cheeses instead of just one or two. It also arrived right on time, which I appreciated. Overall, it was a simple but really nice gift, and I’d definitely consider sending one again.

The shipping cost seemed fair, so I can’t really complain about that. I was glad it wasn’t overpriced, but the overall experience was just kind of average for me.

No issues at all in the end, it actually got here faster than I expected. Shipping was really quick, and everything went smoothly.

I ordered a cheese gift for Christmas and was a little worried about it getting there on time, especially with holiday shipping being so unpredictable. It arrived exactly when they said it would, which was a big relief. Everything was packed well, the cheese was in good shape, and my family really enjoyed it. It was an easy gift that actually worked out, so I’d definitely order again around the holidays.

I ordered a gift basket from the Wisconsin Cheeseman catalog and it was... simple. The item numbers helped a lot, so I wasn’t sitting there guessing what I was adding or anything. Checkout was quick too, which I always appreciate. It arrived when it was supposed to, and my parents said the cheese and sausage were really good. So yeah, I’d probably order again, especially for the holidays or if I need a gift and don’t want to overthink it.

I’m sure I ordered this earlier in the day, or maybe it was the night before, I kind of lost track, but either way everything showed up exactly right. No missing items, no weird mix-ups, and the cheeses were all the ones I picked. It made the whole order really easy, and I was happy with it.

One of the cheese boxes showed up a little smashed, probably from shipping. I emailed them about it and, to be fair, they fixed it quickly with no hassle. I did kind of expect a simple apology since it arrived damaged, but otherwise I appreciated how easy they made the whole thing.

I ordered a gift box from wisconsincheeseman.com sometime around the holidays, I think maybe late November or early December, and thought the price was fair for what came in it.

The cheese and sausage were both good. Nothing super fancy or gourmet, but tasty, nicely packed, and the portions were better than I expected.

Shipping took a little longer than I was hoping, though I can’t remember the exact day it showed up, so I’m knocking off one star for that. Still, for the money, I’d order again, especially if I needed an easy gift...

The box showed up neat and didn’t look tampered with, which was a relief. The cheese was still cold enough when I opened it, though I’ll admit I was a little suspicious at first and checked everything carefully. No real fuss in the end

Everything tasted super fresh and rich. I’d say the cheddar was my favorite — it’s got a nice sharp kick to it that I really liked.

I ordered a cheese box for my dad, and yeah, a couple of the items ended up being out of stock, so they sent substitutions instead. it wasn’t the end of the world, and I don’t think it’s worth making a huge fuss over. The replacements they picked were actually good, and my dad liked everything. I do think it would’ve been nice if they had let me know before shipping, just so I wasn’t surprised. But everything showed up in good shape, tasted fresh, and overall it was a good order. I’d buy from them again, hopefully next time with a little more in stock

The cheese was okay overall, just not quite as fresh-tasting as I was hoping. A few pieces were really good, but others felt kind of bland, if that makes sense. For the price, I guess I expected the quality to be a little more consistent.

I ordered from wisconsincheeseman.com the tracking made the whole thing stress-free. I got updates when it shipped, while it was on the way, and again when it was out for delivery, so I never felt like I was in the dark.

Everything arrived right when the tracking said it would, which I really appreciated because I hate the idea of missing a delivery or having something sit outside too long. No constant porch-checking or guessing needed. It was a good experience, and I’d definitely order again.

They definitely have a lot of cheese options, which is great if you like having choices. I found a few really good ones, but it was almost too much to sort through, and I wish things were a bit easier to compare or organized better.